Last Updated on December 17, 2024
The Chevrolet Silverado 1500 has been a part of the full-size pickup truck market for decades. These Chevy trucks are renowned for their exceptional towing capabilities, powerful engine options, and rugged durability. However, like all vehicles, certain model years stand out for their reliability. Others have garnered notoriety for having persistent issues.
Whether you’re in the market for a new or used Silverado, or simply curious about the truck’s evolution, understanding which generations are better and which are worse can help you make informed decisions. Let’s explore the best Chevy Silverados… and some of the worst.
Best Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Model Years
Many of the Silverado 1500 model years are fantastic choices for those seeking a dependable and capable full-size pickup truck.
2005 and 2006 Silverado
These model years from the first generation are some of the most reliable and trouble-free Silverado models to date. With fewer reported issues compared to their contemporaries, the 2005 and 2006 models offer a solid combination of power, capability, and dependability.
2007 Silverado
If you purchase a used 2007 Chevy Silverado, you can expect great things. This award-winning pickup truck offers improved powertrain options, a comfortable interior, and fewer reported issues than many other Silverado models.
2019 – Present Silverado Models
The latest variations of the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 are currently being praised for their overall quality, advanced features, and reliable performance. Their strong engines offer decent gas mileage and have received few complaints. Thus far, any current-generation Silverado model would make an excellent choice for work or for leisure.

One of the worst model years for the Chevy Silverado 1500 was 2014.
Worst Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Model Years
While the Silverado 1500 has enjoyed a reputation for durability and reliability, certain model years have become infamous among buyers.
2002 Silverado
This model year from the first generation is notorious for engine and brake malfunctions. Specific complaints cited excessive oil consumption, faulty engine cooling, and other dangerous malfunctions.
2012 and 2013 Silverado
These models are among the worst years in the Silverado 1500’s second generation. Consumers complained about transmission, engine, and interior accessory problems. If you’re considering buying a used truck, count these models as some of the Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid.
2014, 2015, 2017 Silverado
All three of these year models come from the third generation; they’re the three most complained about Chevrolet Silverado models to date. These are the Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid, without question. Think twice about buying a used truck from any of these iterations. You’re likely to find electrical issues, rusted brake lines, problems with the intake manifold, and so many more issues it’s difficult to name them all.

This Chevy Silverado 1500 comes from the very first generation.
First Generation: The Groundwork (1999-2006)
The first generation Silverado in 1999 marked a transition from the long-running “C/K” series pickups, popular in the 1960s. This new generation offered a modern, refined, and more comfortable interior, yet still retained the ruggedness and capability expected from full-size trucks. Also included were driver message centers and Vortec V8 engines.
While the early years of this generation (1999-2003) were generally well-received, some owners reported issues with the automatic transmission and excessive oil consumption. The 2002 model year stands out as particularly problematic, with numerous complaints related to the brakes, engine, and fuel system. The latter part of this generation (2004-2006) saw improvements in overall reliability with no major problems. The 2006 model, in fact, is cited by some as one of the best years for the first generation Silverado, evidenced by a decrease in consumer complaints.

This model comes from the second generation of the Chevy Silverado 1500.
Second Generation: Refinement and Power (2007-2013)
The second generation of the Silverado 1500, introduced in 2007, brought significant enhancements to interior quality, safety features, and powertrain options. This generation saw powerful engine choices, including the capable 6.2-liter V8. And unlike the previous generation, this one made use of two and four-wheel drivetrains. Buyers were so pleased with this next Chevy Silverado that the 2007 model year won North American Truck of the Year.
However, the later years of this generation (2012-2013) were plagued by various issues. The 2012 model year encountered plenty of transmission, engine, and interior accessory problems. The following model year had more of the same problems, and if that wasn’t bad enough, it received a higher number of complaints surrounding the vehicle body and paint.

The third generation of the Chevy Silverado 1500 came with a fresh design and new features.
Third Generation: Modern Refinement, Modern Problems (2014-2018)
The third generation Silverado 1500 came in 2014. It brought a fresh design, improved fuel efficiency, and a host of advanced technology features to the market. General Motors introduced a new EcoTec3 engine, which resulted in stronger performance and fuel economy.
However, these four years did not produce the most reliable Chevy Silverado models. The earliest years (2014-2015) were an unmitigated disaster for the Silverado. The 2014 version has some of the highest number of complaints in Chevy history. The Silverado released the following year had fewer complaints, but is still the second highest complained-about model in the vehicle’s history. There were air conditioning problems, engine problems, transmission complaints, and many more complaints. The list goes on.
Results did improve somewhat for the Silverado model years that followed. The 2016 model experienced less complaints, and the 2018 model experienced the least within this generation. But both still reported the same problems, as well as certain electrical problems, steering wheel concerns, and brake failure.
In comparison to other trucks, this generation of Chevrolet Silverados 1500 were neither ideal family vehicles nor work trucks. These were the Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid. However, change was on the horizon.
Fourth Generation: The Current Era (2019-Present)
The pickup trucks of the fourth generation were brought to consumers in 2019. Unlike older models, these Silverado models boast a more aggressive exterior, a more spacious and technologically advanced interior, and a range of powertrain options. Examples would be the powerful 6.2-liter V8 and a fuel-efficient turbocharged 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine.
While the reliability of this latest generation is still too new to definitively assess, none of them have a poor rating, which means the best years for the Chevy Silverado could be soon to come. The pickup truck with the worst rating this generation is the 2019 model, and the complaints somewhat surpass the 2018 model. After that, the numbers drop.
The latest Chevrolet Silverado lineup has been generally well-received, with owners praising the truck’s performance and overall quality.

One of the best model years for the Chevy Silverado 1500 was 2007.
Common Issues and Potential Problems
Chevrolet Silverado models all come with their fair share of pros and cons, some of which have repeated throughout the generations. If you’re looking to buy one, car dealerships should supply you with all the relevant information for your desired vehicle. However, aside from making sure you take the truck for a test drive, also be on the lookout for these common problems:
Transmission Problems
The Silverado’s most notorious for transmission problems– they’re the most common issues with the brand, and they can have several causes. The most common issues include the car bucking or jerking, the car shuddering, hard shifts between gears, or general ‘jerkiness’. Some of the more severe transmission problems include losing the ability to go into first or fourth gear, the transmission entering “limp home” mode (which restricts the car to second and third gear or reverse gear), and the car suddenly downshifting into first gear.
These transmission issues can be caused by failed shift solenoids or by issues with the software in the car’s PCM. Model years particularly affected include 2002, 2012, and 2017. Chevrolet’s even faced several recalls thanks to these problems.
Excessive Oil Consumption
Many owners have reported excessive oil consumption, particularly in the early model years of each generation. This issue can be caused by various factors, including faulty piston rings, valve guides, or other engine components.
One of the most common causes, however, is faults with the Generation 4 Vortec engine and its Active Fuel Management system. The AFM system is supposed to disable engine cylinders when you’re not using them to help you save gas. Unfortunately, it was faulty, especially in the years between 2010 and 2014, which are definitely some of the Chevy Silverado model years to avoid. The flaws in the system meant that oil would frequently end up in the combustion chamber. It would get burned up, and your Silverado would chug oil like a Captain Planet villain.
It’s normal for a high mileage engine to go through fuel quickly and inefficiently. But the Generation 4 Vortec engine is bad enough, even when it’s relatively new, that you want to take precautions to avoid these oil issues. You can get an aftermarket device that plugs into your engine and disables the AFM system. If the AFM hasn’t already damaged your engine, this device can keep it from doing so. General Motors also recommends changing your valve cover with an updated design to help with the oil problems.
Fuel System Issues
All trucks can have fuel issues; it’s the nature of the internal combustion engine. But the Chevy Silverado 1500 has some special fuel system issues, thanks, once again, to the AFM system.
The oil problems are the first horseman of the Silverado apocalypse. They lead to much, much worse problems later on. Leaking oil passes through the pistons and accumulates on the engine’s cylinders, reducing the engine’s horsepower and damaging the engine. If you’re particularly unlikely, it can even lead to a misfire.
The AFM system is really only a problem in second and third generation Silverados, and it’s worth pointing out that most Silverados that featured the AFM don’t have serious problems. The AFM’s failures are a pretty serious flaw with the truck model, but most Chevy Silverados won’t experience problems with it. This isn’t the Ford Pinto.
Hydraulic Valve Lifter Issues
A hydraulic valve lifter controls a car engine’s valves, regulating how much gas is going into the engine. If it fails, the valve will get stuck and stay closed, and then your car won’t start. It’s the automotive equivalent of a heart attack. Worse, a collapsed lifter can hit the camshaft, tearing off tiny metal shavings that can cause some real damage to your engine. And the AFM system makes Chevy Silverados more prone to hydraulic valve lifter issues.
If you’re having hydraulic valve lifter issues, you might hear a ‘tick’ or ‘chirp’ sound from your engine. Your car might not start easily; it might misfire or stall. You might see a “check engine” prompt on your dashboard. If you’re really unlucky, your car might give out in the middle of an intersection. So, if your Chevy Silverado starts ‘ticking’, that’s a ticking time bomb; get it to the mechanic immediately.
Electrical System Issues
Electrical system problems, such as faulty sensors, wiring issues, and malfunctioning electronics, have been reported across various model years. The most common sensor issues are in the oil pressure gauge. When damaged, it might display an oil pressure of zero, or flash the “check oil” light repeatedly.
But all the other dashboard gauges (including, worryingly, the speedometer) are prone to issues. You might hit a bump and have your entire dash turn off, or have the battery light turn on even when your car is fully charged. These issues are generally caused by faulty motors in the sensors or by bad solder connections. Thankfully, it’s an easy fix for a mechanic.
The 2012, 2014, and 2016 models are most prone to these issues. Since they’ve already got the Generation 4 Vortec engine, these are definitely some of the Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid.
Window Issues
The Chevy Silverado has some commonly reported issues with windows. One common issue is that the power windows will stop working. This can be caused by some of the electrical issues we mentioned earlier- bad solder connections, faulty motors, or damaged switches. It can also be caused by a broken window regulator (the part of the vehicle that actually moves the windows up and down), but this is less common. This isn’t a serious issue, but it’s one you need to address in case your vehicle’s electrical system has more serious issues.
Another common window issue is that the rear windows may start to leak. This is commonly caused by faulty window seals or a bad gasket around the brake light. If you find water on the back seat of your car, or are seeing wet carpets and water staining, you should take your car to the mechanic. Compared to some of the issues on this list, it’s a minor problem, but again, it can show more serious problems in the car’s electrical system.
All in all, being aware of these potential problems can help you, as the prospective buyer, make informed decisions and budget wisely.

Despite having various repeat issues, the Chevy Silverado 1500 has been a mainstay in the automotive industry.
Frequently Asked Questions
When considering the purchase of a used Chevrolet truck, potential buyers often have questions regarding reliability, common issues, and which Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid. Here are some frequently asked questions and their answers:
Which Silverado models have transmission problems?
2002 Silverados and Silverados from the 2012-2017 model years had the most transmission-related complaints. Vehicles from the fourth generation have mostly avoided this issue.
Which Silverado engine is most reliable?
While engine reliability can vary based on maintenance and driving conditions, the 5.3-liter V8 and the 6.2-liter V8 engines are generally regarded as some of the most reliable and durable options in the Silverado lineup.
Which Silverado engine is least reliable?
If you’re looking to buy a Chevy Silverado, you want to avoid the Generation 4 Vortec engine. The Gen 4 Vortec is a 5.3-liter V8, and those are normally quite reliable– but its Active Fuel Management system causes many, many problems. The AFM system is a major factor in why the 2012 and 2014 Silverado model years are notorious for engine problems. You want to avoid a Gen 4 Vortec engine at all costs– any Chevy Silverado 1500 year model with a Gen 4 Vortec engine is one of the Chevy Silverado 1500 model years to avoid.
Which year 5.3 engine should I stay away from?
The Generation 4 Vortec engine is the least reliable V8 engine used in Chevy Silverados. Its AFM system causes problems with the engine, the fuel system, and sometimes even the e makes the third generation Silverados some of the Chevy Silverado 1500 model years to avoid.
Is it better to buy a used or new Silverado?
While a new Silverado offers the latest features and a full warranty, a well-maintained used model can still provide excellent value and reliability, but at a lower cost.
The oldest models of Silverado are extremely reliable and have already lasted for two full car generations. The models made between 2010 and 2020, however, have design flaws that make them less reliable– the AFM system, in particular, might give you problems if you’re planning to use your Silverado as a family vehicle.
But either a used or new Silverado can be a great purchase, if you’re careful and do your research. What you ultimately decide should depend on your budget and intended use.
How many miles can a Silverado 1500 typically last?
A Silverado 1500 can easily last 200,000 miles. However, the longevity of the truck depends on various factors, including driving conditions, load hauling, and maintenance history.
What is the most common problem with Chevy Silverado trucks?
Transmission issues and excessive oil consumption are among the most commonly reported problems with Chevy Silverado trucks. These issues are often caused by the Gen 4 Vortec engine’s Active Fuel Management system, and if you can pick up a Silverado that doesn’t use it, you’ll be happier in the long run.
Silverados are also prone to engine problems and various concerns with the electrical system.
Which is better, a Silverado 1500 or Ram 1500?
The choice between a Silverado and a Ram 1500 often comes down to intended use and specific features desired. Both trucks offer capable performance, a range of powertrain options, and various trim levels to suit different needs and budgets. It’s worth noting that some of the Chevy Silverado’s worst years were some of the Ram 1500’s best. But the Silverado and the Ram are equally reliable, and when they do break down, they can both suffer from transmission and engine issues. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preferences.
Which is better, a Silverado 1500 or a Ford F-150?
Again, the choice between a Silverado 1500 and a Ford F-150 often comes down to personal preferences. They’re approximately equal in terms of performance, features, and reliability. One factor you may want to take into account is that some of the Chevy Silverado’s worst years were some of the Ford F-150’s best. If you’re interested in a used car from 2014, the Ford F-150 is the way to go; conversely, if you’re interested in a used car from 2006, you want the Chevy Silverado.
Conclusion
The Chevrolet Silverado 1500 has a rich history and a loyal following among truck enthusiasts and professionals alike. While certain model years have garnered praise for their reliability and overall quality, others have been marred by persistent complaints that make them the Chevy Silverado 1500 years to avoid.
If you’re considering a used Silverado 1500, do your research. Look into the specific model year, know its issues, and figure out vehicle’s maintenance history. Consulting reliable sources, such as owner forums, expert reviews, and reliability ratings, can provide valuable insights and help you make an informed decision.
By understanding the best and worst years for the Silverado 1500, as well as the most common issues to watch out for, you can increase your chances of finding a reliable and capable truck that meets your needs and expectations.
If you’re looking to find a pickup truck that is used and well-maintained, one great place to start looking is with Municibid! Municibid sells government surplus vehicles on auction. The prices are often fairly low, and your used Chevy Silverado might have belonged to the fire department or the parks department.